Jim Huggins (jkhuggins) wrote,
Jim Huggins

  • Mood:

CTV British Columbia- B.C. university introduces grade worse than F - CTV News, Shows and Sports --

CTV British Columbia- B.C. university introduces grade worse than F - CTV News, Shows and Sports -- Canadian Television

This is fascinating. It brings a whole set of interesting arguments into play.

On the one hand, this makes a lot of sense to me. The problem with "merely" failing a student who cheats is that, the vast majority of the time, that student wasn't going to pass in the first place. Consequently, there's really no reason for that student not to cheat ... they might get away with it, and failing isn't any worse than they were going to do themselves. An über-fail has at least the feel of something more descriptive.

On the other hand, this smacks of a sort of "scarlet letter".  Is a one-time mistake worthy of a permanent mark on a transcript?  Is there no room for rehabilitation, or redemption? 

The system described above provides an interesting middle ground ... yes, you can get an über-fail, but it's upgraded to an "ordinary" fail after some number of years.  I suppose that's an interesting compromise.  (Frankly, people don't look at transcripts much once you get your first job.)


  • Perseverance

    In sixth grade, I was a student in Mrs. Fitzpatrick's class at Harrison Elementary School in Inkster, MI. One day, substantially into the year, we…

  • I miss harmony.

    (Warning, long, self-indulgent, emo post. Read on at your own risk.) Several years ago, as my patient family will attest, I fell into a YouTube…

  • Thoughts on Yom Kippur, from an American Christian

    Today, I've been noticing a number of posts on my social media feeds from my friends who are observing Yom Kippur. Many of them posted versions of…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.